Under-reporting of Suicide in an Irish County
Abstract
It is clearly important to have accurate figures on suicides, but official statistics may not always reflect the true numbers of suicides. In this paper, the authors describe how the files of all deaths reported to the coroners of County Mayo, Ireland, for the period 1978-1992 were examined. Those deaths considered to be suicide by the authors were abstracted. Of these deaths, it was found that 7.3% had not been officially registered. The remainder were coded to three different categories in official returns: suicide, undetermined, and accident. In all, 35% of deaths were, in the authors' opinion, miscoded or unregistered. The authors compared these three groups on a number of demographic variables with the expectation that if suicide deaths were being miscoded to undetermined and accident, no significant difference would be found between the three groups. This was found to be the case other than for mode of death. The authors found the greatest miscoding was for deaths due to drowning. The authors recommended that changes be made in the reporting and coding system for suicide deaths in Ireland.
References
Suicide rates in Ireland. Psychological Medicine , (1983). 13 , 385– 391
1962).
Government Publications Office (The registration of deaths in the west of Ireland. Journal of the Irish Medical Association , (1980). 73 , 269– 270
The truth about suicide in Portugal. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica , (1989). 80(4) , 334– 339
The social meanings of suicide . Princeton University Press (1967).
Suicide in Cork and Ireland. British Journal of Psychiatry , (1990). 157 , 533– 538
Suicide in a rural Irish population. Irish Medical Journal , (1991). 94 , 14– 15
Miscounting Suicides. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavia , (1992). 85(1) , 15– 16
Suicides in Dublin. British Medical Journal , (1966). , 1393– 1396
Suicide in Dublin: 1. The under-reporting of suicide and the consequences for national statistics. British Journal of Psychiatry , (1975). 126 , 301– 308
Irish Law Reports Monthly , (1984).
A consideration of the validity and reliability of suicide mortality data. Suicide and Life Threatening Behavior , (1989). 19(1) , 1– 16
Adequacy of official suicide statistics for scientific research and public policy. Suicide and Life Threatening Behavior , (1993). 23(4) , 307– 319
The adequacy of suicide statistics for use in epidemiology and public health. Canadian Journal of Public Health , (1991). 82(1) , 38– 42
Do statistics lie? Suicide in Kildare and in Ireland. Psychological Medicine , (1990). 20 , 867– 871