Psychiatric Diagnoses and Suicide: Revisiting the Evidence
Abstract
Abstract:Background: The key role of prevention and treatment of mental disorders in the prevention of suicide is widely acknowledged. Which specific disorders need to be targeted remains to be conclusively demonstrated. Aims: To re-examine the presence of psychiatric diagnosis in cases of completed suicide from a global perspective. Method: A review of studies reporting diagnoses of mental disorders in cases of completed suicide with or without history of admission to mental hospitals. Results: Most cases were from Europe and North America (82.2%). The majority (98%) of these had a diagnosis of at least one mental disorder. Among all diagnoses, mood disorders accounted for 30.2%, followed by substance-use related disorders (17.6%), schizophrenia (14.1%), and personality disorders (13.0%). Conclusions: The mental health paradigm in suicide prevention covers just a part of the problem. Antisuicide strategies focusing exclusively on the identification and treatment of depression need to be reconsidered. In addition to this, other mental disorders should be targeted, in particular alcohol-use disorders and schizophrenia. More emphasis should also be placed on psychosocial and environmental interventions diminishing and counteracting stress.
References
Arato, M , Demeter, E , Rihmer, Z , Somogyi, E Retrospective psychiatric assessment of 200 suicides in Budapest. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1988). 77, 454– 456Asgard, UA Psychiatric study of suicide among urban Swedish women. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1990). 82, 115– 124Barner-Rasmussen, P Suicide in psychiatric patients in Denmark, 1971-1981. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1986). 73, 449– 455Barraclough, B , Bunch, J , Nelson, B , Sainsbury, P A hundred cases of suicide: Clinical aspects. British Journal of Psychiatry, (1974). 125, 355– 373Bertolote, JM , Fleischmann, A , De Leo, D , Wasserman, D Suicide and mental disorders: Do we know enough?. British Journal of Psychiatry, (2003). 183, 382– 383Bertolote, JM , Fleischmann, A Suicide and psychiatric diagnosis: A worldwide perspective. World Psychiatry, (2002). 1, 181– 185Beskow, J Suicide and mental disorder in Swedish men. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1979). Suppl., 277–Beskow, J , Runeson, B , Asgard, U Psychological autopsies: Methods and ethics. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, (1990). 20, 307– 323Beutler, LE , Barchas, JD , Marzuk, PM The contribution of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy research to national mental health care: Introduction to the special series. Archives of General Psychiatry, (1996). 53, 670– 672Black, DW , Warrack, G , Winokur, G The Iowa record-linkage study I. Suicides and accidental deaths among psychiatric patients. Archives of General Psychiatry, (1985). 42, 71– 75Boardman, AP , Grimbaldeston, AH , Handley, C , Jones, PW , Willmott, S The North Staffordshire suicide study: A case-control study of suicide in one health district. Psychological Medicine, (1999). 29, 27– 33Brown, M , Barraclough, B Partners in life and in death: The suicide pact in England and Wales 1988-1992. Psychological Medicine, (1999). 29, 1299– 1306Cantor, CH , Hill, MA , McLachlan, EK Suicide and related behavior from river bridges: A clinical perspective. British Journal of Psychiatry, (1989). 155, 829– 835Caspi, A , Sugden, K , Moffitt, TE , Taylor, A , Craig, IW , Harrington, H , McClay, J , Mill, J , Martin, J , Braithwaite, A , Poulton, R Influence of life stress on depression: Moderation by a polymorphism in the 5-HTT gene. Science, (2003). 301, 386– 389Cavanagh, JTO , Owens, DGC , Johnstone, EC Suicide and undetermined death in southeast Scotland. A case-control study using the psychological autopsy method. Psychological Medicine, (1999). 29, 1141– 1149Cheng, ATA Mental illness and suicide: A case-control study in East Taiwan. Archives of General Psychiatry, (1995). 52, 594– 603Chynoweth, R , Tonge, JI , Armstrong, J Suicide in Brisbane—a retrospective psychosocial study. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, (1980). 14, 37– 45Conwell, Y , Duberstein, PR , Cox, C , Herrmann, JH , Forbes, NT , Caine, ED Relationships of age and axis I diagnoses in victims of completed suicide: A psychological autopsy study. American Journal of Psychiatry, (1996). 153, 1001– 1008Copas, JB , Robin, A Suicide in psychiatric in-patients. British Journal of Psychiatry, (1982). 141, 503– 511De Leo, D , Evans, R , Neulinger, K Hanging, firearm, and nondomestic gas suicides among males: A comparative study. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, (2002). 36, 183– 189De Leo, D Getting closer to suicide prevention. British Journal of Psychiatry, (2003). 182, 457– 458Safety first: Five-year report of the National Confidential Inquiry into suicide and homicide by people with mental illness . London: Department of Health Publications (2001).
Dunn, RL , Donoghue, JM , Ozminkowski, RJ , Stephenson, I , Hylan, TR Longitudinal patterns of antidepressant prescribing in primary care in the UK: Comparison with treatment guidelines. Journal of Psychopharmacology, (1999). 13, 136– 143Foster, T , Gillespie, K , McClelland, R Mental disorders and suicide in Northern Ireland. British Journal of Psychiatry, (1997). 170, 447– 452Goldacre, M , Seagroatt, V , Hawton, K Suicide after discharge from psychiatric inpatient care. The Lancet, (1993). 342, 283– 286Goldstein, RB , Black, DW , Nasrallah, A , Winokur, G The prediction of suicide: Sensitivity, specificity, and predictive value of a multivariate model applied to suicide among 1906 patients with affective disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry, (1991). 48, 418– 422Gustafsson, L , Jacobsson, L On mental disorder and somatic disease in suicide: A psychological autopsy study of 100 suicides in northern Sweden. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, (2000). 54, 383– 395Hagnell, O , Rorsman, B Suicide and endogenous depression with somatic symptoms in the Lundby study. Neuropsychobiology, (1978). 4, 180– 187Hawton, K , Arensman, E , Townsend, E , Bremner, S , Feldman, E , Goldney, R , Gunnell, D , Hazell, P , Van Heeringen, K , House, A , Owens, D , Sakinofsky, I , Träskman-Bendz, L Deliberate self harm: Systematic review of efficacy of psychosocial and pharmacological treatments in preventing repetition. British Medical Journal, (1998). 317, 441– 447Healy, D Lines of evidence on the risks of suicide with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, (2003). 72, 71– 79Henriksson, MM , Aro, HM , Marttunen, MJ , Heikkinen, ME , Isometsa, ET , Kuopposalmi, KI , Lönnqvist, JK Mental disorders and comorbidity in suicide. American Journal of Psychiatry, (1993). 150, 935– 940Hirschfeld, RM , Dunner, DL , Keitner, G , Klein, DN , Koran, LM , Kornstein, SG , Markowitz, JC , Miller, I , Nemeroff, CB , Ninan, PT , Rush, AJ , Schatzberg, AF , Thase, ME , Trivedi, MH , Borian, FE , Crits-Cristoph, P , Keller, MB Does psychosocial functioning improve independent of depressive symptoms? A comparison of nefazodone, psychotherapy, and their combination. Biological Psychiatry, (2002). 51, 123– 133King, EA , Baldwin, DS , Sinclair, JMA , Baker, NG , Campbell, MJ , Thompson, C The Wessex recent in-patient suicide study, I. British Journal of Psychiatry, (2001). 178, 531– 536Lawrenson, R , Watts, G , Tylee, A , MacDonald, T Pattern of antidepressant prescription in general practice: Lessons from the MediPlus database. Primary Care Psychiatry, (1999). 5 (Suppl. 1), S3– S7Leon, AC , Keller, MB , Warshaw, MG , Mueller, TI , Solomon, DA , Coryell, W , Endicott, J Prospective study of fluoxetine treatment and suicidal behavior in affectively ill subjects. American Journal of Psychiatry, (1999). 156, 195– 201Linehan, MM Dialectical behavior therapy for treatment of borderline personality disorder: Implications for the treatment of substance abuse. NIDA Research Monograph, (1993). 137, 201– 216Mann, JJ A current perspective of suicide and attempted suicide. Annals of Internal Medicine, (2002). 136, 302– 311Minois, G Histoire du suicide [History of suicide]. Paris: Fayard (1995).Mishara, BL Suicide in the Montreal subway system: Characteristics of the victims, antecedents, and implications for prevention. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, (1999). 44, 690– 696Modestin, J , Hoffmann, H Completed suicide in psychiatric inpatients and former inpatients. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1989). 79, 229– 234Neulinger, K , De Leo, D Suicide in elderly and youth populations. How do they differ?. In D De Leo, (Ed.). Suicide and euthanasia in older adults: A trans-cultural journey. Göttingen: Hogrefe/Huber: (2001).Nowers, M , Gunnell, D Suicide from the Clifton suspension bridge in England. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, (1996). 50, 30– 32Ohberg, A , Vuori, E , Klaukka, T , Lönnqvist, J Antidepressants and suicide mortality. Journal of Affective Disorders, (1998). 50, 225– 233Phillips, MR , Li, X , Zhang, Y Suicide rates in China, 1995-1999. Lancet, (2002). 359, 835– 840Read, DA , Thomas, CS , Mellsop, GW Suicide among psychiatric in-patients in the Wellington region. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, (1993). 27, 392– 398Rich, CL , Young, D , Fowler, RC San Diego suicide study I. Young vs. old subjects. Archives of General Psychiatry, (1986). 43, 577– 582Robins, E , Murphy, GE , Wilkinson, RH , Gassner, S , Kayes, J Some clinical considerations in the prevention of suicide based on a study of 134 successful suicides. American Journal of Public Health, (1959). 49, 888– 899Rorsman, B Suicide in psychiatric patients: a comparative study. Social Psychiatry, (1973). 8, 55– 66Shah, AK , Ganesvaran, T Inpatient suicides in an Australian mental hospital. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, (1997). 31, 291– 298Shneidman, ES The psychological autopsy. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, (1981). 11, 325– 340Spijker, J , Bijl, RV , De Graaf, R , Nolen, WA Care utilization and outcome of DSM-III-R major depression in the general population. Results from the Netherlands Mental Health Survey and Incidence Study (NEMESIS). Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (2001). 104, 19– 24Suominen, KH , Isometsa, ET , Henriksson, MM , Ostano, AI , Lönnqvist, JK Inadequate treatment for major depression both before and after attempted suicide. American Journal of Psychiatry, (1998). 155, 1778– 1780Tondo, L , Jamison, KR , Baldessarini, RJ Effect of lithium maintenance on suicidal behavior in major mood disorders. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, (1997). 836, 339– 351Van Heeringen, K , Hawton, K , Williams, JMG Pathways to suicide: An integrative approach. In K Hawton, K Van Heeringen (Eds.), The international handbook of suicide and attempted suicide. Chichester: Wiley (2000).Vijayakumar, L , Rajkumar, S Are risk factors for suicide universal? A case-control study in India. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1999). 99, 407– 411Wasserman, D Ed. Suicide—An unnecessary death . London: Dunitz (2001).Winokur, G , Tsuang, M The Iowa 500: Suicide in mania, depression, and schizophrenia. American Journal of Psychiatry, (1975). 132, 650– 651World report on violence and health . Geneva: World Health Organization (2002).
World health report 2001: Mental health: New understanding, new hope . Geneva: World Health Organization (2001a).
Innovative care for chronic conditions. Meeting report 30-31 May 2001 . Geneva: World Health Organization (2001b).
Report on a workshop on suicide prevention in China, Beijing, China, 22-24 March 2000 . Geneva: World Health Organization (2001c).
Report on a workshop on suicide prevention for countries in the South-East Asia Region, Colombo, Sri Lanka, 06-08 September 1999 . Geneva: World Health Organization (1999).
Primary prevention of mental, neurological, and psychosocial disorders . Geneva: World Health Organization (1998).
Zilber, N , Schufman, N , Lerner, Y Mortality among psychiatric patients—the groups at risk. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (1989). 79, 248– 256